Two tribes

On the second anniversary of the Brexit vote, thousands headed to London protests. On Pall Mall , anti-Brexit campaigners with their EU flags. Alongside the Thames a strange version of pro-Brexit UKIP marched. Angry at betrayal , immigration, Islam and the establishment

On Pall Mall over 100 thousand gathered. The mood seemed unhappy rather than outraged. Although the Brexit vote has been said to disenfranchise the young, many protesters were elderly. It was very middle-class. There was a stage performing comedy skits, an artist selling his Brexit portrait and lots of witty placards. They set off past a large Eid festival in Trafalgar Square chatting away. It was all very pleasant. The march ended in Parliament Square where a stage awaited. Activists Tony Robinson, Gina Miller ; politicians Vince Cable and Caroline Lucas gave speeches. The crowd chanted ironically: “ Where’s Jeremy Corbyn.”

What do they want? Another referendum would be good, a vote on the final deal, a soft Brexit at the very least.

250 metres away (272 yards after Brexit) on a closed off Abingdon Street another stage awaits another Brexit march. For these marchers 23rd June is Independence Day but the event was called Brexit Betrayal . Maybe three thousand paraded along Milbank. A mixed bag of UKIP, Free Tommy Robinson campaigners, Generation Identity and the Football Lads Alliance. Chanting: “ Whose streets , our streets.” They were notably younger and angrier than the remainers.UKIP leader Gerard Batten’s gave a speech comparing the referendum to Waterloo, Trafalgar and VE day but said Brexit was being stolen by a remainer establishment.

After the march, organisers from both sides complained about the lack of media coverage, as is routine. Claimed protest numbers had been underestimated, as is routine. Batten estimated 10K had turned up and remainers said as many as 500k.

But two years after the referendum as Brexit meanders along no-one is listening. There was no Independence Day celebration. The free-market Tories who agitated against EU membership for decades barely noted its passing on social media.

On Independence Day 2018, UKIP – the party that did the most to make it happen – are reduced to an anti-Islam sect around whose dimming light alt-right groups cluster. The 16 million that backed Remain are represented by protesters listening politely to Baldrick from Blackadder.

Whatever Brexit is, neither tribe seems to want it but they don’t know anyone who can stop it

Brexitannia The Movie : a review


A few days after the EU referendum film-maker Timothy Kelly set off for UKIP Land, Clacton-on-Sea, to interview voters. He ended up travelling the country recording the thoughts of over 200 people to create the documentary Brexitannia. Beautifully shot in wide-screen monochrome and cut-down to fifty Brits in a Leave/Remain ratio reflecting the 52 to 48% result. The country explains why it voted the way it voted.

He presented his work at Picturehouse Komedia and described how in a cynical world it’s difficult getting anyone who’ll speak to a camera. He used nine regional fixers to ease the way, avoided direct questions and let his subjects express their views. Apart from one happy Armageddon forecaster he took care not to throw anyone under the bus.

The main part of documentary is funny, relaxed and natural. The subjects chatting to the camera as if it’s what they do all day. It cuts between the regional accents and stereotype-breaking speakers to gradually build a picture. What comes out of the film is a confusion. Why did we vote Leave? Immigration was the big issue and being ruled remotely by a vague grey-suited EU. There were some telling insights but also bent cucumbers and jihadis.


The second part of the film called Experts is less balanced. Noam Chomsky and others expounding their left-wing theories. If anything it shows the distance between those who dissect politics and the voters whose actions they dissect.

In a Q&A Timothy Kelley said he would like to shoot a sequel in 20 years time so the same people could reflect on how things had gone. But as the clocks go in back 2017 his film, shot in the sunny summer days of 2016, already seems so long ago. No one talked about trade deals, Ireland or a Brexit Bill. Leave voters were optimistic of change but a over a year later nothing has changed.

Commentators have gone round in circles trying to explain the Brexit vote. Was it due to: Project Fear, a backlash against the elite, revolts in the Labour heartlands ? As leading-Leaver Michael Gove said: “We don’t need experts”. Watch Brexitannia;  the reason for Brexit – you can only feel it .


The last of the greengrocers

My local greengrocer closed last month. From a chain of four David Rhodes shops only one survives. Mine was ramshackle, tatty and permanently cold but also warm and friendly .

That it was June and they hadn’t taken down the Xmas tree sale sign was a sign the end was near . That it had been there since the previous Christmas showed the end was a long-time coming .

Fifty metres away on either side of the road lurk a Sainsburys and a Tescos Express .

I said: “ You can’t compete.”

Errol, about 60, had worked at David Rhodes for years said : “ Our prices are better than theirs, it’s the rent and business rates that does us. It costs 375 quid a day just to open the place. “

Their prices were better for a few things but the supermarkets beat them on most. And how much easier is it to pick up tomatoes at the same time, in the same place as the pasta.

I would go their once a week and fill my bag with vegetables. If they weren’t sorting out the display one of the the rotating cast, who manned the shop from early morning to late at night, would be sitting on a low stool in the corner rolling a cigarette.

They knew customers and passers-by by name. Chefs from nearby restaurants would hurry in, pick-up a few lemons and leave, promising to pay later.

They advised me; To save leak leaves to make soup, roast the new potatoes and the cheap Chinese garlic was a waste of time. I now buy two ready-trimmed leak sealed in plastic. They’re cheaper. But were my locals’ fresher and did they taste better? in my imagination they do.

They’d knock down the price a bit if the goods looked damaged or they wanted to get rid of something. Surprise veg like cauliflower shaped broccoli would appear seemingly at random for a week. I could buy a couple of tomatoes or a handful of herbs. Always cash no cards. 


If I’d been away , Errol , something of a local personality, would want to know where I’d been, even if I was hundred yards away and he had to shout to find out.

In truth I feel guilty. I know local shops are important, I was amazed they survived for so long  after the supermarket chains opened . I know they needed my custom and I’d miss them when they’re gone. But I’d stopped bothering to walk 50 metres.

I asked Errol what would happen to him ?

“ Don’t know what I’ll do now “. he said. “ Something will turn up.”

The surviving  David Rhodes greengrocer , Portland Road, Hove.

Brighton’s most expensive MP is……..

Caroline Lucas is Brighton and Hove’s costliest MP according to a Government Watchdog. Independent Parliamentary Standards Association (IPSA) data shows she claimed £174,555 in expenses in 2015-16 over £40K more than Hove MP Peter Kyle

To be fair to MP Lucas, MP Kyle didn’t take up his job until after the May General Election so even allowing for Start-Up expenses his monthly costs are higher. 

The IPSA was set up due to the 2009 Parliamentary Expenses Scandal . MPs now have to disclose details of even the smallest claims  which the IPSA publishes on their user-friendly  website. Simon Kirby’s East Brighton and Peacehaven constituents can see his office April gas bill was only £1.36 and in May , Caroline Lucas spent £2.64 on bin-bags.

In 2015, of 605 MPs Caroline Lucas is 156th most expensive, MP Kirby 416th and Peter Kyle 532nd. Due to travel, Scottish and Northern Irish MP’s tend to rack up more expenses . The DUP’s Jim Shannon is the UK’s highest claiming Member at £245,931 . The cheapest by far is Kettering Tory Philip Hollobone who spent less than £9k, employs no staff  and always travels 2nd class. 


Philip Hollobone MP

I emailed MP Hollobone to ask how he managed this. He replied within 20 minutes and said that as I wasn’t his constituent he didn’t have to tell me. An impressive response time for a one man operation

With the introduction of the IPSA came new rules. MPs outside London can no-longer use  their second home allowance to buy a property in London. Travel outside their usual constituency-to-Westminster route has been limited and receipts are required for all claims. New rules and transparency may prevent another duck house scandal but since 2009 , despite austerity, our representatives have found new ways to spend our money. Their expenses have risen 61% from £70 million to over £113 million.

It’s not about Bobbies on the beat – PCC Sussex 2016

On the 12th May  Conservative Katy Bourne was sworn in for her second four year term as Sussex Police and Crime Commissioner (PCC) having easily won a lack-lustre campaign.

The PCC elections use a supplementary vote system and although Bourne didn’t win 50 % of first preference votes and a run-off was required, her majority over Labour increased from 2012.

Sussex PCC elections

The first PCC elections in 2012 had an abysmal turn-out with Staffordshire recording the lowest at 12%,  Sussex achieved 15.3 %.

In 2016, helped by having local council and Mayoral elections on the on the same day, turn-out increased. England and Wales averaged 26%.  Sussex aided by council elections in Adur, Hastings and Crawley reached 22.5%

PCC Bourne subtracted 15.3% from 22.5% to get 42% .

Katy Bourne


The only public event in the campaign was a round-table debate on Radio Sussex at 9 O’clock on a working Tuesday morning. Judging by social media activity not many voters were listening in. All four challenging candidates had similar messages. They would stop Police cuts and put more bobbies on the beat.

LibDem  James Walsh said: ” Cuts would lead to the loss of 700 front-line officers.” and  “the  public wants PCs and PCSOs they can talk to.”

Labour’s Michael Jones said that bobbies on the beat were integral and PCSO numbers could be maintained.

Patrick Lowe, for UKIP, would tear up the current Police plan and recruit more officers.

The Greens’ James Doyle said: ” Bobbies on the beat are the eyes and ears of the Police force.”

But Katy Bourne replied: “Bobbies on the beat is a twentieth century policing model and has to be changed for modern-day crime challenges. ”

Election results showed Ms Bourne received most votes in every Sussex council area except Brighton and Hastings.


In the 2012 campaign Ms Bourne, a local councillor, had promised a PCSO in every community. With police funding cuts this seemed an impossible promise to keep, and was. She now says police numbers are operational matters decided by Sussex Chief Constable Giles Yorke.


Sussex Police Numbers

YearPolice Officers PCSOs

The 2015 Sussex Police Plan pledges more cuts and a move away from bobbies on the beat, many officers are to be based at six main response hubs which will cover Sussex.

Chief Constable Yorke writes: ” The size of the financial challenge means we will need to reduce the size of our workforce by 700 officers.” Three hundred police staff will also go.

The Chief Constable says he has made cuts of £50m but may need to make £57m more.

So the 2016 Sussex PCC election wasn’t about bobbies on the beat although voters reading Conservative campaign leaflets and taking a quick glance at PCC Bourne’s achievements might think it was.


Katy Bourne Election Campaignleaflet




Hove – Brexit or not

EU Flag West Pier Brighton and a lampost

Saturday was a day-of-action for Remain in the EU referendum. Every day is a day-of-action for Leave. In Hove, two Ins and an Out. Labour, Greens and Vote-Leave had set up stalls. None were confident of winning, all were concerned about a low turn-out and conflicted about their allies in their cause.

Green-In Andy

Remainers apologise for the EU. On the Green-In stall overlooking Brunswick Square. Andy said: “We know there’s a lot wrong with the EU.”  but workers rights and the environment are the Greens main reasons for staying-in. Andy felt we belonged in Europe and connections with European Greens were important but it was strange being on the same side as the Tories. He thought most people were fed up with the campaign and a low turn-out would lead to Brexit. Vote_Leave George Street Patricia

Leavers are angry about the EU. Patricia on Georges Street was angry that the UK paid the EU £350 million every week and said that this controversial claim wasn’t controversial. She was exasperated that the majority of people didn’t seem interested and if they knew the facts they would vote to Leave

She said. ” Someone  told me that they had voted Remain in last weeks PCC election.”

The Leave campaigners were from Ukip’s Grassroots-Out who lost out to Vote-Leave in being designated as the official Brexit campaign. Ukip have worked for years to get a referendum but now find themselves volunteering for a Brighton & Hove Vote-Leave campaign controlled by Labour Councillor Tom Bewick. Patricia was uneasy that Vote-Leave leaders were talking about a second referendum so winning on the 23rd June would mean renegotiation not Brexit.

Labour-In Ann Georges St Hove

Just along Georges Street,  Ann for Labour-In , with a Jeremy Corbyn lapel badge said: “We know the EU needs to change.” but ” the EU had won workers rights and protected the environment. ” She predicted a low turn-out which might help Vote-Leave win and was perplexed with ending  up on the same side as ” Cameron and Gideon ” .

But what would happen if they lost :-

Anne said the worst thing about losing was Farage, Johnson and Gove winning. There would be no protection from the Tories but thought it might give Labour a chance  at the next election .

Patricia for Leave didn’t know what would happen to Ukip but thought they would carry-on fighting.

Andy for Greens-In said :  ” If I wake up on the 24th and we’ve lost I’ll be absolutely devastated .”

Is Rambling Dan rambling ?

To avoid being viewed as just grey suited bureaucrats, politicians need to cultivate a public image hence David Cameron’s support for West Villa United and Vladimir Putin’s bare-chested horse riding.
To escape the slavery of Brussels – South-East MEP, Daniel Hannan; author, columnist, and leading-light in the Brexit campaign loves to take long walks in the bucolic English countryside.

Hannan Dandelions

This Tweet was deleted after it was pointed out that it would be the sweet sights and sounds of Germany. The photo was taken from an article about the use of dandelions by a German car tyre manufacturer .

German Dandelions

Most Leave and Remain campaigners have been accused of manipulating facts and MEP Hannan is no exception. Jonathon Portes an economist at The National Institute of Economic Research wrote  :

While both sides in the referendum campaign use statistics “as a drunk uses a lamppost” (for support, rather than illumination), Mr Hannan has a habit of simply inventing them.

Is his countryside loving image an invention ?

Hannan Hawthorn WalesPhotos’s of every gig, game and traffic accident are shared but part of the point of sharing is to say, I was there.

John Ball was there, but not in Hampshire as he said via e-mail :

The photo used by Daniel Hannan on 6 May 2016 is a copy of a photo in the ‘ Images of Wales ‘ feature on my website: 
I took the photo myself eighteen years ago on 20 May 1998. The photograph shows May blossom in a hedgerow near Godre’r Graig in the Swansea Valley of South Wales, that’s over 150 miles from Hannington in Hampshire where Mr Hannan claims to have been.
However, I am not subscribed to Twitter and I do not have time contact Mr Hannan to point out his deception.
Skylark Germany

The Skylark. Obviously a professional photograph and it’s a stock photo from Alamy taken in Hess, Germany.  This idyllic view of the countryside is spoiled by the Northern Europe and UK Skylark population  being on the highly endangered Red List mainly due to intensive farming. The EU directive to protect wildlife was, and still is, under threat from Farming lobby groups but conservation groups and other MEPs are fighting back.

Hannan Ramsgate sunrise


Did Mr Hannan get up early in the morning to enjoy this Ramsgate sunrise and share it with the world ? No, Julia, from Germany, did. He said via e-mail:

As you can imagine I’m not impressed to hear that MEP Daniel Hannan is using my photo without my permission. I should really sue him, shouldn’t I?
Anyway, my name is Julia Höfer-von Seelen and the photo was taken on the 11th of November 2014.


Daniel Hannan’s anti-EU stance and countryside loving image plays well with the people who elect him; South-East Conservative Party Members who put him top of their party list for the 2014 EU elections. In the EU elections voters choose a party not an MEP. So in a traditionally Tory voting region,  Mr Hannan was a shoe-in to return to Brussels where he has been a fixture since 1999 .

As one of the most high-profile Leave campaigners a Brexit vote could be rewarded with a safe Tory seat in Westminster and higher office. The right public image can help you go along way.



Daily Telegraph

Daily Telegraph


PCC 2012 -The forgotten election

On the 5th May England and Wales go to the polls to elect 41 Police and Crime Commissioners (PCCs). The inaugrural PCC elections in November 2012 were notable for the electorate not going to the polls.
There was an average voter turnout of 15%. Staffordshire was lowest with 11.6% and the BBC reported on a polling station in Wales where nobody voted. The Electoral Commission said it was the lowest recorded level of participation at a peacetime non-local government election in the UK
The low turnout was one reason a high number of independents beat the party-backed rivals.

The PCC elections use a supplementary vote system. If no candidate gets more than 50% of the electors’ first preference vote then the top two receive the other candidates’ second preference votes.
In Sussex, Katy Bourne, a Conservative councillor from Haywards Heath was elected. The turnout was 15%

PartyCandidate 1st Round Cotes1st Round %2nd Round VotesTotal
ConservativeKaty Bourne5963531.5%2039380028
LabourGodfrey Daniel4076521.5%1483755602
IndependentIan Chisnall3893020.5%
UKIPTony Armstrong2932715.5%
Liberal DemocratDavid Rogers2057910.8%

First preference votes from Sussex’s thirteen council counting stations show Labour doing well in Brighton and Crawley. The Tories received more votes in rural areas. The LibDems dived bombed and independent Ian Chisnall finished second everywhere except the final count.

Ian Chisnall PCC candidate

Ian Chisnall

Mr Chisnall said: If he had done better in Brighton, where he lives, and beaten Labour for second place he  may have overtaken Katy Bourne in the run-off, as party supporters tend to choose an independent for their supplementary vote rather than a rival party.
Evidence from the other PCC elections back him up , Independents won more secondary votes in 15 out of the 16 regions where they reached the second round. In neighbouring Hamphire, Michael Mates, the Tory grandee, led by almost five thousand in the first round but independent Simon Hayes received 30 thousand more second preference votes in the run-off and was elected.

The low turn-out nationwide questions the legitimacy of the results and an Electoral Commission review blamed lack of candidate information for the lack of interest. This time a booklet will be delivered to every household detailing who is running and what for. With local elections being held on the same day the Commission expects a higher level of participation.

But when only 8 % of people know the name of their PCC and only 39% know they have one maybe Independents will continue  running  what many believe should be apolitical independent offices.

It’s alright for some – Brighton’s housing boom

House prices in Brighton & Hove have risen by 490 % in the last 20 years. The highest percentage increase of any town or city in the country.

Data from the ONS  shows the Median House Price in Brighton & Hove  rose from £50k in 1995 to 290k in 2015. The highest of the 113 towns and cities analysed. The lowest was Burnley with 148%.


The North/South property-price divide is widening. In the Median-House-Price-Increases League, The South dominate the top ten positions and northern towns occupy the bottom. In the last twenty years the lowest house prices have risen the least.


The Brighton property market slowed during the economic recession but has surged during the recovery. It’s good news for Brighton’s estate agents and home-owners.

But for first-time buyers and those who missed the property boat there are few affordable options.


More working more not-working

Almost seven thousand more people are out-of-work in Brighton & Hove compared to the corresponding period last year. Government data released last week shows the UK with 31.4 million in-work, a rate of 74%, the highest figures ever, but in Brighton & Hove employment fell further from it’s September 2014 peak.

Chancellor George Osborne is happy

ONS data shows unemployment numbers in Brighton & Hove falling slightly but an increase of almost seven thousand in the  Economically-Inactive since last September.

When it comes to labour statistics The ONS puts everyone, aged 16-64, into one of three boxes. Anybody doing any paid work is Employed, Anybody actively looking for work is Unemployed. Everybody else is Economically-Inactive.
The main Economically-Inactive groups are unemployed students, people looking after home and family, retired people, the  long term sick and disabled.

The rise of the Inactive, in the city,  isn’t down to any particular group but seems to be a general trend. The ONS also estimates the Economically-Inactive who want to work. In the year up to September there was an increase of six thousand people who want a job but aren’t looking for one.

The majority of the –  Don’t-want-a-job people are home-makers, parents, carers and full-time students but who are the Out-of-work, who want to work but are not looking for work ? It’s an important question economically and may hide real poverty and real unemployment levels.

Catherine Barnham at the ONS says,  Child-care costs being higher than wages is a factor but we don’t ask

those who do not want a job and are not seeking one whether they are available to start work. Similarly, people who want a job but are not looking if they are available to start.

So we don’t know.